A Secondary 1 Design and Technology project begins with something a person needs to do. In this workbook, a pupil designs a small paper or card holder for reusable activity slips at a classroom station. They watch how people use the station, sketch three different ideas, make two quick models and compare what happens when someone tries them. A family can work through the exercise with folded card, scrap paper and removable tape.
Design and Technology is part of the lower secondary common curriculum under Full Subject-Based Banding. Posting Group 1 is used for Secondary 1 posting. The D&T lesson is part of the common curriculum that pupils take in their mixed form class. This original home exercise illustrates design and testing skills. Use the teacher’s brief, materials, deadlines and instructions for any school assignment.
- Identify one user, one task and the moment in which a difficulty occurs.
- Write a design brief that leaves room for several solutions.
- Give each sketch a different way of helping the user, then compare what each idea costs in space, effort and material.
- Build two paper versions and use the same short tasks to test them.
- Record what a tester actually did, make one change and test it again.
- Explain what the revised design does well, the conditions under which it was tested and what you would check next.
Contents
Sections 1 to 5
Sections 6 to 9
Start with a task the user already does
Imagine a classroom where groups use two colours of reusable activity slips. A green slip shows the question a group is currently working on. A blue slip carries a follow-up challenge. At the end of an activity, each group returns both slips to a station on a side table. The slips will be used again in the next lesson. Ideally, the pupil who clears the table can collect each colour as a stack.
In the imaginary classroom, there is one flat tray with two pieces of labelled paper on the bottom. It works when only a few slips are present. Near the end of a lesson, the labels become covered and some slips end up across both sides. The pupil clearing the table now has to sort the whole tray. This closely defined problem gives the student room to consider different designs.
When you start a project, draw the station and show what happens before, during and after a return. Write “approach table,” “find a place for each slip,” “return both slips” and “leave so the next person can step up.” Draw an extra box below for the pupil who clears the station. Ask which action becomes slower or more awkward as the table gets busier. This is a clue about where to spend the design time.
A narrow starting problem is easier to investigate. “People need a better classroom” could mean anything from lighting to noise. “The pupil collecting slips has to sort two mixed colours when the tray fills” establishes a user and a circumstance. You may eventually discover another problem worth solving, such as a low label being hard to read from the side. Keep it next to the main problem and decide whether it belongs in the same project.
Set up a small observation
For home practice, lay six green and six blue paper slips on a table. Each can be about 6 cm across and 9 cm long. Write “Question” on the green ones and “Challenge” on the blue ones, so testing can include the printed words. If you only have one colour, mark each slip with a matching shape and word. Fold a piece of paper around the back and sides of your pretend tray, and put the two labels flat on the base. Use only lightweight paper for the task.
Have a sibling, parent or friend try returning slips one pair at a time. Ask them to imagine that the next person is waiting. You can return some slips beforehand to simulate a tray that is already partly full. Observe three things. Where does the tester look first? What do they do when one label is covered? Can they finish using one hand if they prefer? Record the action and what was happening at the time. If you discuss a real classroom project involving classmates, follow the teacher’s instructions before observing or keeping any record of another pupil.
An example note might read, “On return four, the green label was under the pile and the tester placed the green slip across the middle.” This note is more useful than “Tester got confused.” It shows the student a particular thing to change and later check. If the tester later explains why they moved the slip, add their comment separately beside the observed action. The two may tell you different things.
Keep assumptions visible
A student might assume each group always brings back two tidy slips together. A group may return one slip a few minutes later, a blue slip may be upside down, or two may be stuck together. You do not need to design for every imaginative accident. Choose which variations are frequent enough to matter. For this project, test one return when the station is empty, one with a partly filled station and one from the side of the table. These conditions matter because they change what the user can see and reach.
You can also draw three small sketches showing the viewpoint of a person standing straight in front of the table, approaching from the right and moving away. Circle which words they can see from each viewpoint. Keep decisions about colour and lettering open until you know what the user sees.
Write a design brief and set the tests early
A brief tells the designer what outcome to work towards. One usable brief for the station reads, “Design a small holder for a shared activity station that helps pupils return two kinds of reusable paper slips and lets the pupil on duty collect each kind as a stack.” At this stage, the word “holder” leaves the student free to propose channels, open wells, shelves or another folded form.
A good specification gives the student something observable to check. A holder that is “convenient” might be pleasant to use, but different people will read that word differently. A clearer statement is that someone approaching from the right can see what kind of slip each opening accepts while several slips are already present. The student can ask a tester to do this and see what happens.
| What the holder should do | What the student can check |
|---|---|
| Fit on an available base of about 18 by 14 cm | Place the holder inside a rectangle of that size drawn on scrap paper. |
| Let a person identify both return places | Ask the tester to match two slips with the openings before giving any directions. |
| Keep two piles separate when partly full | Load each holder with three slips per place and add six new returns. |
| Let the pupil on duty pick up one pile at a time | Have the tester clear the question slips first and record the challenge slips that move, if any. |
| Stay in place during ordinary use | Look for sliding, creasing or lifting when a slip is returned or the pile is removed. |
| Use materials suitable for a home paper model | Check that the model can be made from folded paper or card and removable tape. |
The size and slip count are choices for this workbook. A teacher may provide different constraints. If the holder is 16 cm wide and the marker boundary is 18 cm, the design fits the paper rectangle. You should still check what happens when a user’s fingers move outside the holder to collect the slips. Physical fit and room to operate the object are two different observations.
Decide what matters most when two ideas tie
For the shared station, a reasonable order of priorities is finding the right place to return a slip, preventing the piles from mixing, and lifting each pile. Use those outcomes to guide a choice when two models have especially different features. A model could look tidy because its sides are tall, but the collector may have to pick the slips out one by one. A low tray may be easy to empty, yet a user standing at the wrong side may miss which place is theirs.
Keep one line for preferences that are free to change. A front label might have a blue border and a question label might have a triangle. The student can choose how to draw either feature, as long as each sign is readable and the system makes sense to the user. A clear written or shape cue is especially useful when lighting is poor or the card colours are similar.
Contents · Previous section · Next section
Sketch three genuinely different ideas
Begin with a top view and a front view for each idea. A top view shows where the piles go and whether the holder fits the available space. A front view shows what a person would see when reaching the table. Annotate a path for the slip entering the holder and another for fingers removing it. A sketch can be rough and still reveal exactly where paper, walls and fingers need to go.
Idea A. A low tray with a full divider and two upright signs
Draw a rectangle 17 cm wide and 13 cm deep. Put a divider down the middle from the back to the front. Give the two openings generous widths so that a 6 cm slip can be set down without careful aiming. Put a folded sign behind each bay. The signs face front and rise behind the slips. Keep the front edge low enough for someone to lift a stack.
This design has clear places and the open bays suit quick use from above. The full divider can stop a slip that starts drifting into the other bay. The back signs remain visible when the base is full. A low edge offers access, though a sideways pull might drag the paper tray. Consider whether the side from which pupils arrive is close enough for them to see both signs.
On the sketch, shade the divider and label it “Folded spine to prevent slipping across.” Draw a thumb and finger on one stack so you can check how much room they need. Add a “Side view” showing the top of the slips sitting lower than the words on the rear sign. This makes the reason for the sign placement visible.
Idea B. Two upright pockets with sloping front lips
Draw two folded pockets standing side by side. The cards sit more upright than in a tray. Each pocket has a front lip about a third as high as a slip, so the card rises above the rim. A label goes directly above each pocket opening. Draw a wider foot across the bottom so the pockets are less likely to topple while a person uses them.
One possible advantage is that there is a visible correspondence between a label and its opening from the front. An upright pocket uses less depth, which leaves more room for hands or a different activity on the shared table. A slot that opens generously can accept slips without fine control. If the front lip is too high or the opening narrows when slips bend, someone may have difficulty clearing a whole stack.
Put three arrows on the drawing. One runs downward into the pocket, another shows where the hand pulls the stack upward and a third shows the direction the pocket might tip. Draw the stable foot beyond both bottom edges. Ask how large it can be within the permitted rectangle. The footprint of the support counts when you decide whether the idea really saves space.
Idea C. Two offset shelves with a label at each exposed edge
Draw one low shelf in front and one slightly raised shelf behind. Each is wide enough for a stack and has a small side wall. The lower shelf allows one stack to slide out from the front. The raised shelf keeps the second stack visibly separate and lets the user lift it from above. Put a short label where the student can see the front opening and another on the face above the back shelf.
This arrangement groups both stacks within a narrower space than a side-by-side tray. Consider which slip is returned more often and whether it belongs on the easiest shelf. The raised shelf may ask more of a student reaching across the table. It also needs enough support to hold its shape when pressed lightly. You can draw the shelf folded from stiff card and mark where a paper brace might go.
A student could choose this idea for a narrow classroom ledge with good access from the front. On a wider table where pupils approach from the side, they may prefer Idea A. Keep the third idea in the journal even if you build another version. It gives you something specific to explain about choosing one construction over another.
Use a quick comparison to choose two prototypes
For this workbook, make A and B. The wide open tray and small upright pockets ask the user to move in distinctly different ways. The choice sets up a comparison about visibility, stability and collecting the slips. If you have time to make only one model, make a small full-size section of each idea first. Build a single bay for one design and one pocket for the other. You can learn something about finger access before making a complete holder.
If your child immediately chooses the prettiest sketch, ask them to name a test they expect it to pass and a test that may expose a weakness. “A looks easiest to clear, but the lower edge could let slips out” gives the student a good reason to investigate. The next step is to observe whether that happens under the planned test. A preference becomes usable when you can explain what it predicts.
Contents · Previous section · Next section
Make a model that can teach you something
Use folded light card if you have it and ordinary paper if you do not. Tease sharp folds by pressing with your fingers. Bring lengths together with removable tape. Make the openings with folds, separate pieces or ordinary school-safe tools under appropriate supervision. You can use pre-cut paper pieces and avoid cutting altogether. Keep the models small, easy to change and light enough to handle safely.
For the tray, start with a base that fits your marked area. Lay two slips side by side and leave space between them for a folded strip. Place the strip as the divider. For the first model, it can stop a finger’s width short of the front edge so everyone has room to reach the stacks. Fold two cards into broad standing tents, one for each end of the base. Write the labels on faces directed toward the approach path. Add a simple front rail made from a slim fold, leaving space for a finger to get under each pile. You have enough for a first test when the divider stays in place and a user can see both labels.
For the pockets, fold loose sleeves around each stack as a guide and remove the stack before securing the outside with tape. Leave a top opening long enough for a slip to enter without bending. Form the front lip from a short folded piece and tape the pair to a broad base. A spare piece of card folded into a triangle behind the pockets can help them stay upright. Keep the first version simple. The purpose is to find out how a person handles the opening and whether the pocket stays standing.
Use the same twelve slips in both tests. A thicker piece of card may make a pocket behave differently from a thin slip. If you mainly want to compare the shape, keep the model card similar where possible and mention any differences when you report the results. If the only available paper is thin, you can still compare visibility or ease of sorting. A weak paper edge says less about the strength of a future final design than it says about where the forces act in the model.
Make a fair test sheet
On one sheet, write A and B in separate columns. Under each, create a row for an empty station, a partly full one and an approach from the right. Put the same number of cards in the same list of places before each partly filled test. Give the same instruction each time: return each slip to its place, then pick up the complete question stack and leave the other stack in the holder.
Agree what you will count in advance. Record a misplaced slip if it ends up in the other pile or across the divider when the tester finishes. Track an extra action if they regrip, steady the holder with their second hand, or ask you where a slip goes. You may note elapsed time when the tester is comfortable with it, but watch the actual movements. Fast motion can hide why a design works for some people and causes a problem for others.
Try letting one person start with A and another start with B. A person often works faster with a second model simply because they have already learned the task. Switching the start order does not make two family tests a large study. It helps reveal whether a result appeared every time or only when one version was tried first. Record the order for each tester.
Contents · Previous section · Next section
Read sample results and decide what to change
Here are invented results that show what a small comparison can reveal. Each model had six returns in its partly filled condition. Both people approached from the right in one of their attempts. When checking collection, they each tried to remove the stack closest to the centre of the table.
| Observation | A. Open tray | B. Upright pockets |
|---|---|---|
| Misplaced slips across six returns | One slip rested across the divider. | All six went into the correct pocket. |
| Signs from an approach on the right | One tester paused and turned to read the farther sign. | Both signs were visible when the tester arrived. |
| Collecting one stack | Both testers lifted the whole stack in one movement. | One person held the base as the stack came out. |
| Movement of the holder | The base stayed inside the marked rectangle. | The front corner lifted during the faster removal. |
These examples support two useful conclusions. The pockets guided the return more reliably in this small test. The open tray was easier to clear for these two people. A student can choose which advantage should carry more weight in the shared station. If confusion during a busy return is the main problem, clearer entry matters. If the person on duty cannot spare both hands, a design that lifts when the slips are removed matters as well.
Ask where the slip crossed the tray divider. If it landed above the divider after an angled return, a slightly taller centre strip might help. If the tester slid a slip through a gap near the front, closing the gap or extending the divider could be enough. This is why a small note describing the exact movement helps more than a single score. Each cause suggests a different revision.
The corner of the pocket that lifted suggests a separate line of reasoning. Was the opening so narrow that the stack rubbed against it? Was the foot too short? Did the user pull away from the base rather than straight up? With the same people and setup, you can try one modest change at a time. A paper model is particularly useful here because a folded piece can be swapped without building the whole holder again.
Try one revision and observe it again
Take the tray as an example. Leave its two bays and low front rail in place. Fold the signs so their faces tilt slightly toward the table’s right side. Repeat the right-side approach. Record whether the tester can name both destinations while staying in the approach area. Then try it from straight ahead. A sign improved for one direction may be harder to read elsewhere, so keep both sets of observations.
Consider a specific second change only after that check. Extend the divider to the front edge while keeping its top at the same height. Load the model with the same number of slips and ask the tester to return six new ones. Record whether any return ends across both sides. Clear one stack as before. A narrower bay near the extended front divider could affect finger access, so record whether collection still works.
Suppose the first change made both labels readable from the right, and the second reduced misplacements from one to zero in another six attempts. Those observations are encouraging under the conditions used. You can write that you would test with a different group of people, a more filled tray and headings printed large enough for the classroom lighting. You should also look again at how the person on duty reaches both bays when they stand somewhere different.
Contents · Previous section · Next section
Show the design journey in a short record
Use four pages or four clearly titled spaces. The first shows the user, the task and the problem seen in the old setup. The second shows your three sketch ideas and what each one brings. The third shows the two models, the planned checks and enough data for a reader to understand the comparison. The last shows the change and what happened when you tried it. A date next to a picture or note puts the record in sequence.
A useful caption has a job. “Pocket model” identifies the object. “Pocket model B, before widening the opening. The hand goes up to clear the stack and the right foot lifts” ties a model to an observation. Some people start with a neat sketch while others prefer a picture of folded paper. Choose the form that best shows the feature the reader needs to see. If the teacher asks for a particular format, use it for classwork.
Put the unsuccessful step beside the revision. “The flat label became hidden when a pile grew, so I raised the sign at the back” shows the relationship between a finding and a design choice. “It was impossible, so I improved it” leaves the reader guessing. Your child can practise explaining the before-and-after with the model in hand and often improve the written caption by borrowing words from their spoken explanation.
Worked closing paragraph
“One problem with the first setup was that slips covered the labels at the bottom of the tray. I tried a low tray with upright signs and a pair of upright pockets. Both designs kept their signs above the slips. I kept the tray because both testers could collect a full stack in one movement. During the test one return crossed the divider, and one tester had to turn to read a sign. I angled the signs toward the arrival side and extended the divider to the front edge. In the repeat test, both people could identify the return places from the right, and six more returns stayed in their bays. Before making a classroom version, I would test with a fuller tray and ask more classmates to try collecting each stack.”
This paragraph stays close to what the student observed. It explains why the tray won in this example without claiming that every classroom needs the same solution. If another pupil chooses pockets, their paragraph can be equally strong if they explain why visibility matters in their setting and document whether a revised pocket remains in place during collection.
Contents · Previous section · Next section
A second brief to try independently
Imagine that a classroom keeps two kinds of reminder cards for the end of a group activity. One kind gives students the steps to clean up. The other tells them what to hand in. The teacher wants groups to see both cards at their own table, and the cards currently lie face down among worksheets. Design a small stand that holds two cards where the group can read the headings and return both cards afterwards.
First decide which side of the table the group normally sits at and what happens when they have finished reading one card. If they move it elsewhere, the stand may need an obvious place for a card that has just been used. If the main problem is that cards go face down, the stand may need a shallow tilt so the headings stay visible. Write two checks before making a model. One could be that a person sitting at the far side can identify both headings. Another could be that a person can remove one card without shifting the second.
Try a flat tent, a side-by-side holder, or two angled faces placed back to back. If you borrow an element from the first project, name what changed about the new task. In the return station, the user approached and left. At a group table, the cards stay visible during an activity. That difference may affect the size of the sign, the place you put the stand or the direction in which each face points. Ask your child to explain how their new sketch responds.
Contents · Previous section · Next section
Frequently asked questions
Is Secondary 1 D&T a G1 subject because my child entered through PG1?
At lower secondary, MOE includes D&T among the subjects shared in mixed form classes under Full Subject-Based Banding. A pupil can therefore take D&T with that form class while attending some other subjects in groupings based on subject level. Your child’s timetable shows the arrangements for their school. For upper secondary subjects and levels, use the school’s later options and subject combination guide.
Does my child need to make a finished wooden or plastic product for this workbook?
Paper and light card are enough for testing the shape, reach and visibility in this activity. This workbook’s object is an early model of an arrangement rather than a finished classroom item. For actual class projects, follow the workshop safety guidance and use only materials and tools approved by the teacher.
What if the first model falls over or creases?
Write where it folded or fell and what the person was doing at the time. A model that lifts when a stack is removed shows where it needs support. Another model that bends when slips build up may need a different pocket width or brace. Choose a small change that addresses the observed problem and try the same action again.
Can a parent help with the drawing?
A parent can ask what the user sees, hold a sheet steady or volunteer to test. Let the student make the choices and draw the arrows showing how the object will be used. If someone helps build a home model, the student can note what they did on their own, what was demonstrated and what they tried by themselves afterwards.
How should we use this alongside classwork?
Use it to practise observing, sketching, making an early model or explaining a test before working on a separate teacher-assigned brief. It can also give a child something specific to ask in class, such as how much information should go next to a sketch. Use the actual assignment instructions to decide what your child should submit.
Contents · Previous section · Next section
Official references and further reading
- MOE Full Subject-Based Banding infographic on mixed form classes and the common curriculum
- MOE lower secondary Design and Technology syllabus
- Naval Base Secondary School on Design and Technology projects and curriculum
